What’s next for the Flyers, after the Leo Carlsson offer sheet fallout

The Flyers have discussed alternatives (often framed as “Plan B”) after the Anaheim Ducks matched their aggressive offer sheet for Leo Carlsson.

Quick Context on Carlsson

On July 3, 2026, the Flyers tendered a record 5-year, $90 million offer sheet ($18M AAV) to the restricted free agent center. This would have made him the NHL’s highest-paid player and cost the Flyers four first-round picks as compensation if Anaheim didn’t match.

tsn.ca The Ducks had until July 10 to decide and ultimately matched, keeping Carlsson in Anaheim.

Flyers’ Plan B / Alternative

Flyers General Manager Danny Brière has been aggressive in pursuing a top-line center. If Carlsson didn’t work out, these are some options:

• Adam Fantilli (Columbus Blue Jackets): The top alternative mentioned. The 21-year-old RFA center (3rd overall pick in 2023) had a strong 2025-26 season with career highs (59 points in 82 games). The Flyers could pursue him via another offer sheet or trade. He’s seen as a potential franchise center but carries risks (hasn’t fully lived up to elite expectations yet).
• Other centers via trade or offer sheet: Speculation includes targets like Dylan Larkin (Detroit), Shane Wright, or pivoting to internal development/trade market pieces. The Flyers have cap space and assets but prioritize high-upside young talent.
• Defensive and depth additions: Regardless of the center pursuit, the team has been linked to defensemen (e.g., Zach Werenski rumors, John Carlson interest) and other roster tweaks to build around their young core (including Matvei Michkov, Tyson Foerster, etc.).

The Carlsson move was a bold swing to accelerate contention. With it off the table, expect continued aggression from Brière in free agency, trades, or further offer sheets—though matching is likely for top RFA’s. This offseason is still active as of early July 2026.

Check out our Flyers Nitty Gritty Store

Cool Matvei Michkov merchandise

About Author